- Where you were born/where were you raised? Flossmoor, IL
- Zodiac sign: Aquarius
- What are/were the careers of your parents? Both are retired. Dad was a teacher, and mom worked in the family business.
- Do you have any Siblings? Yes. Three. I’m the third of four, but I’m also the baby of the family…
- Where were you trained? No formal training; just been performing in theatre for nearly thirty years. I did, however, minor in theatre at The George Washington University.
- Current favorite audition song or monologue to use: “A Marriage Proposal” from Falsettos. It’s never actually gotten me cast, but I sure do love singing it.
Why did you want to be a part of Evil Dead? Oh where do I begin? It’s my favorite film series. I’ve been obsessed with the movies ever since I saw Army of Darkness when I was eight (8) years old. Since then, I’ve watched that film at least 100 times. I’ve seen nearly all of Bruce Campbell’s movies, and I mean, he’s made some really REALLY bad ones (coughAlienApocalypsecough). I’ve met Bruce Campbell, each of the ladies from Evil Dead, and the artist who designed the Necronomicon, and I have several signed posters, books, photo-stills, and a very special shot glass. I even own each of the video games associated with the films!
Favorite horror movie? Army of Darkness. A close second is Cabin in the Woods.
Most played song in your music collection: “Judy and the Dream of Horses” by Belle & Sebastian
Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: Pip in Great Expectations
Worst onstage mishap: I forgot the words to my song and just started word-vomiting extraneous noises. Fortunately, it was a goofy scene where the chorus supported me by visibly laughing at my pain. Unfortunately, it was a duet.
Worst costume ever: I honestly can’t think of one. I guess anything with tights before I discovered dance belts.
Worst job you ever had: I’m embarrassed to say, but being a supervisor in the 2010 Census. I was awaiting bar exam results, so I couldn’t practice law yet. I worked with the Census for about five weeks. It was such a haphazard mess with awful management. When I finally got licensed, I was excited to quit that job in order to start the second worst job I’ve ever had: Mechanic’s Lien Litigation Attorney.
Craziest audition story: According to my mom, I was almost cast as the little boy in Lorenzo’s Oil. Allegedly (again, according to my mom, as I have no recollection of it), I went to numerous callbacks, and the casting team made it clear that, if I could roll from my back to my stomach without using my hands or arms, I would be cast (the character has an illness that makes him very sick and unable to use his arms, I guess). I couldn’t do it. They tried for over an hour at my last callback to get me to do it, but it was to no avail. Sadly, I was not cast.
Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: Mendel in Falsettos (see above, re audition song) Fagin in Oliver
What were you afraid of as a child? The illustrations from the book, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark.
Where you were born/where were you raised? Columbia, MD. Lived in Baltimore for four years after college before moving to Chicago
Zodiac sign: Capricorn with Leo Rising/Moon sign (outgoing and friendly but judging and manipulating our friendship the whole time. You're welcome for becoming a better person)
What are/were the careers of your parents? Mom is an early childhood educational administrator and dad is a home repair man and at one time was a professional skier.
Do you have any Siblings? Two older. We're all J's - Jaimie, Jonathan, and Josh. Parents are John and Jessica too.
Where were you trained? BFA in Acting from University of Maryland, Baltimore County.
Current favorite audition song or monologue to use: I sang "Bound to You" by Christina Aguilera (Burlesque soundtrack) at a cabaret recently and I'm looking for any excuse to use it at an audition.
Why did you want to be a part of Evil Dead? Who doesn't want to die on stage every night with 7 of your closest frenemies?
Current or recent show in Chicago (other than Evil Dead) that you think is must-see: Snowgirls at Hell in a Handbag was all the absurdity I've ever needed in a holiday Showgirls parody. It was so dumb I loved it.
Favorite horror movie? Stand alone: Cabin in the Woods. Franchise: Scream (2, 4, 1, 3). Ask me next week and I'll have flipped 1 and 4 again.
Most played song in your music collection: Currently the "This is Lizzo" playlist on Spotify. Listen. Love it.
Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: I was in a church musical that took place in a theme park and I played Jay, a custodian who ended up being a Jesus-like character. It was my first "lead role" and then the adults running it decided they didn't feel like doing it anymore so the show never happened. Memories.
Worst onstage mishap: Being cast as Pablo in A Streetcar Named Desire in the 10th grade and saying all of my Spanish lines with a slight French accent because that's what I was studying in school at the time.
Worst job you ever had: One summer I applied to about 20 places before landing a job at a Pier 1 Imports that I kept for two years. The job itself wasn't terrible but I'm still covered in glitter and that was ten years ago.
Craziest audition story: When I was auditioning for my college program they had older students come in and work with you because the department wanted to see you work on your feet and "go for it." I was chasing this girl in circles while reciting a monologue from The Importance of Being Earnest except I was in socks and it was a wooden floor so I promptly slipped and slammed my face into the ground. I got a full scholarship.
Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: If I could just follow Norbert Leo Butz's resume I'd be a happy man.
What were you afraid of as a child? Mediocrity. And bees. I got stung a lot as a kid. By the bees, not by mediocrity.
Our props designer Jeremiah Barr (who is also our set designer, puppet designer, and TD) is creating some magnificent designs for our production of Evil Dead the Musical! Among them is his own take on the iconic Kandarian Dagger that plays a key part in some of the gruesome and hilarious happenings during the show. Check out some photos below of the progress of the props from beginning stages to the finished thing!
Step 1: Enhance a prop dagger with a 'spinal column' handle.
Step Two: Start adding creepy miniature bones and skulls in a pattern around the spinal column handle.
Step Three No, more bones and skulls than that. WAAAAY more.
Step Four: Then we start to paint...starting to look pretty gross and unholy, but is something missing?
Step Five: Oh, right! Blood. LOTS OF BLOOD.
All done! Time to terrify people. Get your tickets now to see this and much more!
- Where you were born/where were you raised? I was born in San Antonio, Texas. Raised in the very small town of Tilden, Texas.
- Zodiac sign: I am an Aquarius, Cancer Rising
- What are/were the careers of your parents? My mother is a nurse. My father is a cattle rancher and business owner.
- Do you have any Siblings? I have two: 1 brother and 1 sister. I am the youngest.
- Where were you trained? I went to an art school in San Antonio, North East School of the Arts (NESA). I then went to the Chicago College of Performing Arts at Roosevelt University. I also attended summer opera intensives during summers in undergraduate - Italian Operatic Experience in Urbania, Italy, Elardo Young Artist Program - Brugge, Belgium, and Taos, NM.
- Current favorite audition song or monologue to use: I use "Anytime" from Infinite Joy and "Dust and Ashes" from Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 most frequently.
- Why did you want to be a part of Evil Dead? It's easy to get wrapped up in the seriousness of theatre and sometimes we lose the joy of just having fun and playing. I wanted to be part of Evil Dead because I felt like it would be a great way to let loose and have fun, while exercising my creative muscles.
- Current or recent show in Chicago (other than Evil Dead) that you think is must-see: 110 in the Shade was great. Neala Barron was incredible in it!
- Favorite horror movie? Good question. I would say Jeepers Creepers and Silence of the Lambs is a tie.
- Most played song in your music collection: "I'm Your Baby Tonight" - Whitney Houston
- Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: Merlin in A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court. It's when I first tapped into my fabulousness and realized I like to play evil roles.
- Worst onstage mishap: I was using a real bullwhip that I learned to crack specifically for a role. I was choreographed to crack the whip to the side but for some reason that day I accidentally cracked the whip down. It went into the pit and nearly hit the pianist's fingers. Needless to say, they took the whip away from me and gave me a stick with a string on it.
- Worst costume ever: I was gargoyle # 2 in Beauty and the Beast in high school (not even a real role). Picture it, a chubby Robert in a periwinkle unitard and a paper mache mask we had made ourselves.
- Worst job you ever had: I was a...mixologist, lets say, at Sonic. I made drinks for a whopping 2 weeks before I realized what I had gotten myself into.
- Craziest audition story: This was recent. My audition was in about 20 mins, so I ordered an uber. As I went to sit down in the car split...my pants ripped clean across my crotch and around to my hind end, revealing my wanker and stanker! Let's just say it was an added layer of stress trying to hide my mishap!
- Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: Sweeney Todd, Javert, Beast, Jud, Elphaba.
- What were you afraid of as a child? Chucky. My brother used to chase me around the blockbuster with the VHS trying to scare me.
- Where you were born/where were you raised? I was born in Germantown, MD. Grew up in Bowie (hometown of Kathy Lee Gifford AND JC Chazes... Ooh la la.)
- Zodiac sign: Leo
- What are/were the careers of your parents: My Mom is an early-education school teacher and Dad is retired from the Dept. of Agriculture and now he plays tennis all day.
- Do you have any Siblings? One brother.
- Where were you trained? AMDA (NYC), though much of my education came from the late, great Bobbi Smith in Annapolis MD.
- Current favorite audition song or monologue to use: None. I end up hating my entire book of audition material. SO IF YOU KNOW SOMETHING THAT’D BE GREAT FOR ME, HIT ME UP!
- Why did you want to be a part of Evil Dead? I’ve been looking for an opportunity to work with Ed, and any chance to fling blood around, I take.
- Current or recent show in Chicago (other than Evil Dead) that you think is must-see: POSEIDON: An Upside-Down Musical! with Hell in a Handbag Productions, opening in March at The Edge Theater ! (I play Nonnie, the catatonic lounge-singer).
- Favorite horror movie? Psycho, The Shining, It Follows...
- Most played song in your music collection: Hamilton cast Album, and Disney Theme-Park mixes.
- Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: I played John in Peter Pan, so I got to fly which was pretty baller.
- Worst onstage mishap: I slipped and fell off of two different stages in my time. Once my pants slit open down the crotch when I kneeled down Center stage. And in Dan Savage’s MIRACLE! I cut my hands open on flimsy stage-lights that were a part of the set more times than not.
- Worst costume ever: I worked for Disney. Let’s leave it at that ...
- Worst job you ever had: I was once the Personal Assistant for this total narcissist who owned a chain of specialty toy stores. My job was mostly lying to people about where he was (including his wife) and why vendors weren’t getting paid. Nightmare.
- Craziest audition story: I plead the fifth.
- Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: The Witch (Into the Woods), Sally Bowles (Cabaret), Desiree in A Little Night Music (one day).
- What were you afraid of as a child? Hotel Showers. That elderly Six-Flags mascot-man.
- Where you were born/where were you raised: -Chapel Hill/Carrboro, NC
- Zodiac sign: -Virgo
- Do you have any Siblings?: -Only child!
- Where were you trained?: -UNC Asheville
- Why did you want to be a part of Evil Dead? -I couldn't resist! It's a delight to be working on a show that you know is going to be a blast for the performers and the audience. Silly, messy, singing fun. And a temporary relief from the stresses of the world.
- Current or recent show in Chicago (other than Evil Dead) that you think is must-see: -I just finished Caroline, or Change which was phenomenal. I'm just now getting back out there and seeing all the other amazing shows going on. Get back to me on that.
- Favorite horror movie? -Good question. I'm not much of a horror movie person. Does The Fly count? The one with Jeff Goldblum, I think is a great movie, and has several moments I have a hard time watching or can't watch at all for gore reasons. Cabin in the Woods is also a blast.
- Most played song in your music collection: -Depends on when you ask me. I'll play one song over and over for months, then not touch it for a long time. I made a Beach Mix for a trip this past August I'm still getting a lot of play out of. Favorites on that mix include: "Pink Toes" by Childish Gambino, "Ghost" by Frankie and Scott Hoying, "Back in the Day" by Erykah Badu, "Mutt" by Blink 182, "Black Lassie" by Cheech and Chong, and "Weird Science" by Oingo Boingo.
- Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: -I got to play Puck in A Midsummer Night's Dream in 8th grade which was great fun, and a role I relished from start to finish.
- Worst onstage mishap: -I've been relatively lucky. Just to name a few that come to mind: I've gone totally blank onstage and forgotten my next line in the middle of a highly emotional and climactic scene. I've also forgotten about a quick change and had to make my entrance without shoes. I've waited for an actor to enter who didn't. The usual.
- Worst costume ever: -Hmm, giant old Snowman costume.
- Worst job you ever had: -Probably working concessions at a movie theater. Not because it was awful, but just because it could be really boring, and seemed like a waste of my valuable time.
- Craziest audition story: -Not sure if it's too crazy, but when I auditioned for Marta in Company in NC, I was offered the role on the spot. Very surreal for me as a performer.
- Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: -Any role in Passing Strange.
- What were you afraid of as a child? -I remember having FOMO fairly regularly as a child. Fear of missing out. I wouldn't even want to leave to go to the bathroom.
- Where you were born/where were you raised: Born and raised in Forsyth, Georgia
- Zodiac sign: Taurus
- What are/were the careers of your parents: My Mother is a retired Special Education Teacher, and my Father is an Attorney
- Do you have any Siblings?: I have one wonderful older brother, Brad
- Where were you trained?: I have degrees in Theatre & Advertising from The University of Georgia
- Why did you want to be a part of Evil Dead? The chainsaw hand. Definitely the chainsaw hand.
- Current or recent show in Chicago (other than Evil Dead) that you think is must-see: Caroline or Change at Firebrand was a revelation.
- Most played song in your music collection: Elysium by Bear's Den
- Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: My first leading role was Oliver in Oliver! in the fourth grade, and I'll never forget it
- Worst costume ever: I once worked at an aquarium, and I dressed up as all sorts of HEINOUS sea creatures and nautical things!
- Worst job you ever had: I mowed a lot of lawns as a teenager
- Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: Up next: Whizzer in Falsettos
- What were you afraid of as a child? I was a decidedly unafraid child - which got me into some trouble.
- Where you were born/where were you raised? Born in Eunice, Louisiana; raised in Ville Platte, Louisiana (about an hour north of Lafayette, LA)
- Zodiac sign? Libra
- What are the careers of your parents? My Father is a State Farm Agent; My Mother is a full-time Mom
- Do you have any Siblings? 1 Sister , Lindsay.
- Where were you trained? University of Louisiana at Lafayette for Bachelors; Texas Tech University for Masters
- Current favorite audition song or monologue to use: Song would be from The Apple Tree; Monologue would be from Jitters.
- Why did you want to be a part of Nightmares & Nightcaps? I’m really into horror flicks. Not that this show is incredibly scary, but I love the dark quirkiness of this show.
- Favorite Twilight Zone and/or Black Mirror episode? Nosedive, Shut Up and Dance, White Bear (couldn’t pick just one!)
- Most played song in your music collection: Right now? The Plastics from Mean Girls the Musical. DONUT COME FOR ME.
- Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager: Jesus – Godspell
- Worst onstage mishap: I’m sure I’ve had one but can’t think of any so it must not have been that bad!
- Worst job you ever had: Working retail at Aeropostale
- (Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: The Baker from Into the Woods, Helena from A Midsummer Night's Dream
- What were you afraid of as a child? Sweetums the Muppet
- Where you were born/where were you raised? Manchester, CT
- Zodiac sign? Leo
- What are/were the careers of your parents? Lawyer, Phlebotomist.
- Do you have any Siblings? One brother.
- Current favorite audition song or monologue to use: song: "No More" from Into the Woods / monologue: Mosca from Volpone
- Why did you want to be a part of Nightmares & Nightcaps? I love Collier's sinister yet witty writing and I can't turn down a chance to play Satan.
- Current or recent show in Chicago (other than Nightmares & Nightcaps!) that you think is must-see: Southern Gothic.
- Most played song in your music collection? SexyBack
- Favorite or most memorable onstage role as a child/teenager? Nigel Rancour in Something's Afoot
- Worst onstage mishap: I almost destroyed a beautiful scrim of Cape Cod for a high school production of Babes in Arms when I jiggled the doorknob of a set within a set and the entire wall came crashing down and then the door followed.
- Worst job you ever had: A dishwasher at Friendly's.
- Role(s) you’ve been dying to play: Mosca in Volpone, The Baker in Into the Woods, Edmund in Lear, Lemml in Indecent, Mr. Applegate in Damn Yankees.
- What were you afraid of as a child? Monsters under my bed.
Nightmares & Nightcaps has been open for a couple of weeks now, and the good reviews have been rolling in! For those of you who are curious, here's a list of quotes and links to the various good press we've been getting:
“Deliciously macabre...[this] quirky, disquieting, ever comedic production nicely showcases Collier’s peculiar tales.” — Barbara Vitello, Daily Herald
“Delightful...a well-chosen and well-acted series of vignettes, from ominous to slyly funny...”” — Crista Zivanovic, NWI Times
“Absolutely hilarious...an excellent production...so good you’ll leave the theater wishing they could have added more of Collier’s sardonic, twisted confections.” — Karen Topham, Windy City Times
“A strange and spooky delight...hilarious, and creepy-crawly scary, both aurally and visually.” — Nancy Bishop, Third Coast Review
“The energetic performers play all of their characters to the hilt...its simplicity pairs nicely with the bitter flavor of Collier’s stories.” — Alex Huntsberger, Time Out Chicago
“A ghoulish delight...John Collier’s works are both witty and acerbic. Black Button Eyes Productions delivers a charming introduction and brilliant homage to the writer.”” — Kerstin Broockmann, Chicago Stage Standard
“A delightful exercise in creepy-crawly quirkiness...Rutherford has found the perfect theatrical equivalent to Collier’s blend of the lethal and the looney.” — Lawrence Bommer, Stage and Cinema
“Rutherford’s latest production is nicely staged, beautifully acted and creatively supported by a team of clever theatrical artisans.” — Colin Douglas, Chicago Theatre Review